This blog post is a vital resource for businesses in Scotland, providing essential information on understanding these penalties, implementing effective checking procedures, and maintaining full compliance with UK immigration law. At JRI, our solicitors have extensive expertise in Scotland Visa and Immigration law and offer critical support to help employers protect their business from these significant financial and legal repercussions.
Understanding Right to Work Checks and Employer Responsibilities
A Right to Work check is a formal procedure that all employers must undertake to verify that a prospective or existing employee has the legal right to work in the UK for the type of work being offered. This process is a foundational pillar of UK immigration control, designed to prevent illegal working. It is a fundamental responsibility that all employers must understand and adhere to, regardless of their size or sector.
The Legal Basis for Right to Work Checks
The legal obligation for employers to prevent illegal working stems from Sections 15 and 21 of the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006. This legislation places a statutory duty on every employer in the UK to conduct checks and provides a ‘statutory excuse’ against civil penalties if an illegal worker is inadvertently hired. This legislation is a UK-wide law, meaning it applies with full force to all businesses and employers in Scotland, from the largest corporations in Glasgow to the smallest startups in the Highlands. Understanding this legal basis is the first step toward recognising the gravity of the responsibility.
Who Needs a Right to Work Check?
The requirement to perform a Right to Work check applies to every single employee, and it must be completed before employment begins. This applies to all individuals, regardless of their nationality, immigration status, or perceived nationality. You must conduct a check for:
- British and Irish citizens: Even for British and Irish citizens, a compliant check must be carried out to establish your statutory excuse.
- Individuals with time-limited visas: This includes sponsored workers on Skilled Worker visas, individuals on Student visas, and others with time-limited leave to remain.
- EU, EEA, and Swiss citizens: For those with settled or pre-settled status under the EU Settlement Scheme.
- Treating employees differently based on their nationality or appearance is not only discriminatory but also exposes your business to legal risk. The key principle is to check every single person, every single time.
Continuous Duty for Employers
For employees with time-limited permission to work in the UK, a Right to Work check is not a one-time event. It is a continuous duty for employers. You have a legal obligation to monitor the expiry date of an employee’s permission and conduct a follow-up check before their current visa or status expires. Failing to perform this continuous monitoring and follow-up check in a timely manner will mean that your statutory excuse expires, leaving your business vulnerable to penalties if the employee’s permission runs out.
Penalties for Non-Compliance: The Costs of Illegal Working
The consequences of failing to conduct proper Right to Work checks or, worse, of knowingly employing someone without the right to work, are severe and can be catastrophic for a business. The Home Office has a tiered system of penalties designed to deter non-compliance and punish those who breach the rules.
Civil Penalties (Fines)
The most common penalty for a Right to Work breach is a civil penalty fine. These fines are issued on a per-illegal-worker basis and have recently been subject to a significant increase. The current penalties are as follows:
- For a first breach: A business can face a fine of up to £45,000 per illegal worker.
- For repeat breaches: If a business has been found to have employed an illegal worker within the last three years, the penalty for any subsequent breach rises dramatically to a fine of up to £60,000 per illegal worker.
- These penalties apply even if the employer was unaware of the worker’s illegal status. The key is whether the employer failed to conduct the correct checks and, as a result, does not have a “statutory excuse.” The purpose of the check is to establish this excuse; without it, the employer is liable regardless of their intent.
Increased Penalties Effective February 2024
The penalty amounts were recently tripled, effective from February 13, 2024. This change signals a stricter approach from the Home Office and a heightened risk for employers who are not fully compliant. The previous maximum fine for a first breach was £15,000, and for a repeat breach, it was £20,000. These new figures underscore the government’s determination to crack down on illegal working and make it clear that a robust and compliant Right to Work process is no longer a matter of choice.
Criminal Offences
In more severe cases, particularly where an employer knowingly employs an illegal worker, they can face criminal prosecution. This is a far more serious matter than a civil penalty. The potential penalties for a criminal conviction include an unlimited fine and a prison sentence of up to five years. An employer is deemed to have ‘knowingly’ employed an illegal worker if they were aware or had ‘reasonable cause to believe’ that the worker did not have the right to work in the UK. This can include situations where the employer failed to act on information that an employee’s permission had expired.
Other Significant Consequences
- The fines and criminal penalties are not the only consequences of non-compliance. Other significant repercussions can include:
- Losing a Sponsor Licence: For employers who hold a sponsor licence to employ international workers, a failure to comply with Right to Work check procedures can lead to a licence downgrade, suspension, or even revocation.
- Damage to Business Reputation: The Home Office publishes a quarterly list of all employers fined for illegal working. This public list can cause significant damage to a business’s reputation, affecting relationships with clients, partners, and the public.
- Director Disqualification: Directors of companies that are found to be non-compliant can face disqualification from holding a directorship for up to 15 years.
- Confiscation of Earnings: The earnings of an illegal worker may be seized, and the employer could face a recovery order to repay any profits made from the illegal employment.
Effective Right to Work Check Procedures for Employers in Scotland
Establishing a robust and compliant Right to Work check procedure is the only way to protect your business from the significant penalties outlined above. The goal is to establish a statutory excuse for every single employee. The Home Office has set out three primary, accepted methods for conducting a compliant check.
Three Accepted Types of Checks
- Manual Document Check: This traditional method involves physically checking original documents from the Home Office’s ‘List A’ or ‘List B’ of acceptable documents. You must meet the individual in person (or via a live video call for a non-digital check). The process involves a thorough inspection of the document, ensuring it is a genuine, original document, and that the photograph and other details match the person presenting it.
- Online Right to Work Check: This is the mandatory method for checking the right to work for individuals who hold an online immigration status. This includes those with a Biometric Residence Permit (BRP) or Biometric Residence Card (BRC), those with a digital status under the EU Settlement Scheme, and most other visa holders. The employee generates a ‘share code’ from the Home Office website, which you then use on the Home Office’s online service to view their immigration status and right to work.
- Identity Document Validation Technology (IDVT) via an Identity Service Provider (IDSP): This digital method is available for checking the right to work of British and Irish citizens with a valid passport. Employers can use a certified Identity Service Provider (IDSP) to verify the authenticity of the passport remotely. The IDSP will carry out the necessary checks, and you must retain a record of their report to establish your statutory excuse.
Key Steps for a Compliant Check
Regardless of the method you use, a compliant Right to Work check must follow these key steps:
- Obtain the correct documents: Ensure you have the original physical documents or the necessary share code for an online check.
- Check the documents: In the presence of the individual, check that the documents are genuine, unexpired, and that the photo and details match the person in front of you. For online checks, you must check the photo on the online profile against the individual’s live image.
- Make a clear copy: Take a clear, unaltered copy of the documents (or a screenshot/PDF of the online profile).
- Record the date: Record the date on which the check was made. This is essential for proving the check was completed before employment began.
Maintaining Records and Follow-Up Checks
Your responsibility doesn’t end after the initial check. You must keep clear, dated records of every check you conduct. For employees with a time-limited right to work, you must set up a system to remind you to conduct a follow-up check before their current permission expires. A well-organised, secure record-keeping system is your best defence against a civil penalty. All records must be kept for the duration of the person’s employment and for an additional two years after they leave.
JRI’s Inclusive Support for Employers in Scotland
JRI is deeply committed to providing accessible and inclusive support to all employers in Scotland. We understand that Right to Work checks can be particularly challenging for small businesses that may lack HR department. Our mission is to ensure that every employer, regardless of their business size or sector, can effectively meet their Right to Work obligations with confidence.
JRI’s Commitment to Diverse Businesses
Our team assists a broad spectrum of Scottish businesses. We work with dynamic small enterprises and startups, helping them establish foundational compliance procedures from day one. We also partner with larger corporations and sponsored employers who require sophisticated systems to manage their diverse workforce. Our expertise spans various industries, from hospitality in Glasgow to the tech sector in Edinburgh, and we provide clear, accurate, and equitable guidance to all our clients.
Guidance for Various Employer Scenarios
Our broad expertise means we are equipped to assist you in various situations:
- New Businesses/First-time Employers: We provide foundational advice on setting up compliant Right to Work checking procedures, helping you start on the right foot and avoid future penalties.
- Growing Businesses: We offer strategic support for businesses that are scaling their operations, helping them implement robust systems that can handle a growing workforce while maintaining compliance.
- Businesses Facing Enforcement Action: For those who are already undergoing a Home Office audit or have received a civil penalty notice, we provide urgent and expert assistance to defend your business and mitigate the financial impact.
How JRI’s Experts Can Protect Your Business in Scotland
The risk of a significant fine for a Right to Work breach is a very real threat to any business in Scotland. JRI’s legal specialists provide crucial, proactive support to help you prevent these penalties, ensuring your business is fully compliant and protected.
Comprehensive Compliance Audits
Our team can conduct thorough, pre-audit assessments of your current Right to Work checking procedures. We will review your systems, inspect your records, and identify any potential weaknesses or areas of non-compliance. This proactive ‘mock audit’ approach allows for timely rectification of any issues, ensuring you are fully prepared for a real Home Office visit.
Training and Policy Development
A key component of our service is providing practical assistance to your team. We can train your HR teams and managers on the correct Right to Work check procedures, ensuring they understand every step of the process. We also assist in developing bespoke, compliant policies and record-keeping systems for your business, creating a clear and consistent process that all staff can follow.
Response to Home Office Enquiries and Challenges
In the event of a Home Office visit, a civil penalty notice, or any formal enquiry, JRI’s team can act as your legal representative. We provide expert legal advice, help you formulate a strategic response, and can challenge fines on your behalf where appropriate. Our presence ensures that your case is handled professionally and that your business is protected from a significant financial and reputational impact. With JRI, you have an experienced legal partner in your corner, ensuring that your compliance is as robust as your business.
