This blog post provides a detailed guide on these mandatory responsibilities. We will explain the legal basis for these checks under the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006, outline who needs to be checked, detail the compliant methods, and highlight ongoing duties. The blog will emphasise the severe penalties for non-compliance and how JRI assists businesses in maintaining a lawful workforce, ensuring all information is accurate and aligned with current UK legislation.

The Legal Basis of Right to Work Checks

The requirement for employers to conduct right to work checks is deeply embedded in UK immigration law, serving a crucial role in maintaining immigration control and preventing illegal working.

Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006

Sections 15-25 of the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006 (as amended) establish the core legal framework for preventing illegal working. This legislation places a clear statutory duty on all employers to verify that every individual they employ has the legal right to undertake the work in question. Failure to do so can result in significant civil and criminal penalties, regardless of whether the employer knowingly employed an illegal worker.

Preventing Illegal Working

The core purpose of right to work checks extends beyond mere compliance; it is about upholding the integrity of the UK’s immigration system. These checks are designed to deter illegal working, which often leads to the exploitation of vulnerable workers, undercutting of legitimate businesses, and tax evasion. By ensuring a legal workforce, employers contribute to a fairer labour market and protect the wages and working conditions of all employees.

Consequences of Non-Compliance

Employers who fail to comply with their right to work obligations face severe civil and, in cases of knowing employment, criminal penalties. However, by conducting checks correctly and according to Home Office guidance before employment commences, employers can establish a “statutory excuse.” This statutory excuse provides a legal defence against civil penalties, even if it later transpires that an employee did not in fact have the right to work.

Who Needs a Right to Work Check?

A common misconception is that right to work checks only apply to foreign nationals. These checks are universally applicable: all individuals undertaking work for a business in the UK require a right to work check, regardless of their nationality.

All Employees, Regardless of Nationality

The universal application of right to work checks is a cornerstone of compliance. Employers must conduct checks on every single prospective employee, without making assumptions based on their nationality, appearance, or perceived immigration status. Singling out individuals based on race or ethnicity could lead to claims of unlawful discrimination.

British and Irish Citizens

Even for British and Irish citizens, right to work checks are mandatory. For British citizens, this typically involves verifying their valid passport or other specified documents from List A of acceptable documents, such as a birth certificate coupled with a National Insurance number official document. For Irish citizens, their valid passport or passport card serves as proof of their right to work under the Common Travel Area arrangements.

EU, EEA, and Swiss Citizens (Post-Brexit)

As of 1 January 2021, the rules changed significantly for EU, EEA, and Swiss citizens who were not residing in the UK by 31 December 2020. Most now need specific immigration status (e.g., status under the EU Settlement Scheme or a work-permitting visa) to work in the UK. Their national passport or ID card alone is no longer sufficient proof of their right to work. Employers must verify their digital immigration status via the Home Office online service using a ‘share code’.

Non-EEA Nationals

Individuals from outside the European Economic Area require a specific work-permitting visa to be employed in the UK. Employers must verify this visa, which specifies their right to work, and any conditions attached to it, such as limitations on working hours or type of employment.

When to Conduct Checks

The timing of right to work checks is critical for establishing a statutory excuse and avoiding penalties.

Before Employment Commences

Employers must complete a compliant right to work check before the individual starts any work for the business, even if it is just for a trial period or induction. It is highly advisable to make any job offers conditional on a successful right to work check. Starting employment without a proper check instantly makes the employer liable for penalties if the individual is later found to be working illegally.

Follow-up Checks for Time-Limited Leave

For employees who have time-limited work permission (e.g., a Skilled Worker visa, a student visa with work restrictions), employers have an ongoing duty to conduct follow-up checks. These must be performed shortly before the employee’s current permission expires to ensure they still hold a valid right to work. Failure to conduct these repeat checks will result in the loss of the statutory excuse and potential liability for civil penalties if the employee continues working without valid leave.

How to Conduct a Compliant Right to Work Check

Adhering to the Home Office’s prescribed methods and key steps for performing a lawful right to work check is essential for establishing a statutory defence against civil penalties.

Three Methods of Checking

The Home Office outlines three primary, approved methods for verifying an individual’s right to work, with specific rules for each.

Manual Document Checks (List A & List B)

This method involves checking original physical documents. Employers must obtain the original documents from either List A (for individuals with an indefinite right to work, like British or Irish passports, or settled status) or List B (for individuals with time-limited leave). The employer must then inspect these documents in person (or via video call as per temporary COVID-era guidance which has now been formalised for some checks), verify their authenticity, check for any work restrictions, and ensure the photo matches the individual. Copies must be retained.

Home Office Online Service (Share Code)

For individuals with digital immigration status (e.g., those granted status under the EU Settlement Scheme, or with a Biometric Residence Permit/Card or eVisa), using the Home Office online service is mandatory. The individual provides a ‘share code’ and their date of birth. The employer then uses these details to access the online service, view the individual’s real-time immigration status, and verify their right to work. It is not sufficient to simply view the share code or the individual’s personal online profile.

Identity Document Validation Technology (IDVT)

For British and Irish citizens with valid passports, employers can use an Identity Service Provider (IDSP) to digitally verify the identity document. This involves using certified technology to remotely verify the passport’s authenticity. While this method can streamline the process, it is crucial to remember that the employer remains liable for ensuring the check is compliant and that the individual has the right to work. The IDSP simply performs the digital identity verification part of the check.

Key Steps for Each Check Method

Regardless of the method used, certain fundamental steps are necessary to establish a statutory defence and ensure the check is robust.

Obtaining Original Documents or Share Codes

It is paramount to obtain original physical documents directly from the individual for manual checks (photocopies are not acceptable for the initial check, except for IDVT). For online checks, you must obtain a valid, current ‘share code’ directly from the individual. Relying on emailed photos of documents or expired share codes will not establish a statutory excuse.

Verifying Authenticity and Consistency

For manual checks, carefully examine documents for any signs of tampering or forgery, ensuring the photograph genuinely matches the person presenting it, and checking the consistency of personal details across all documents. For online checks, compare the photo displayed on the Home Office online service with the individual presenting for work, which can be done in person or via video call.

Making and Retaining Copies

After the check, you must make and retain clear, unalterable copies of the relevant pages of physical documents or screenshots of the online check results. These copies must be dated with the date the check was made and securely kept for the entire duration of the individual’s employment and for a further two years after their employment ends. This record-keeping is vital for demonstrating compliance during any Home Office inspection.

Ongoing Employer Duties and Compliance

Right to work compliance is not a one-time task; it is a continuous obligation that requires ongoing diligence and robust internal processes from all UK employers.

Continuous Monitoring for Time-Limited Leave

Employers must establish effective reminder systems to track the expiry dates of employees with time-limited leave. Follow-up checks must be conducted shortly before the existing leave expires to verify that the employee has obtained new valid permission to work. Failure to perform these timely follow-up checks can lead to severe penalties.

Record Keeping and Audit Trails

Maintaining comprehensive and accurate records of all right to work checks is paramount. This includes copies of the documents or online check results, the date the check was made, and details of any follow-up checks. These records serve as a vital audit trail for Home Office inspections and are essential for establishing a statutory excuse if challenged. Records must be kept securely for the duration of employment plus two years.

Reporting Changes to the Home Office

For businesses that hold a sponsor licence, there are additional, specific duties to report changes to the Home Office via the Sponsor Management System (SMS). This includes notifying them if a sponsored worker leaves employment, fails to turn up for work, or if the business discovers a sponsored worker has lost their right to work. Strict timescales (usually 10 or 20 working days) apply to these reporting duties.

Avoiding Discrimination During Checks

It is critical that right to work checks are conducted consistently and fairly for all prospective and existing employees, regardless of their nationality, perceived immigration status, or ethnic background. Any selective checking based on discriminatory grounds could lead to serious discrimination claims under equality legislation, in addition to immigration penalties.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

The UK Home Office takes breaches of right to work obligations extremely seriously, imposing severe financial and criminal penalties on employers found to be non-compliant.

Civil Penalties

Employers who employ illegal workers due to failed or incorrect right to work checks, even unknowingly, are liable for significant civil penalties. These are financial fines issued by the Home Office.

Current Fine Structure

As of February 13, 2024, the civil penalties for employing illegal workers have significantly increased. For a first breach, employers can face fines of up to £45,000 per illegal worker. For repeat breaches within a three-year period, the fine can escalate to £60,000 per illegal worker. These amounts are a threefold increase from previous levels, demonstrating the government’s intensified stance on illegal employment. In the first quarter of 2025 (January to March), Home Office enforcement action resulted in 748 civil penalty notices being issued, totalling £41.6 million in fines.

Factors Affecting Penalty Amount

The actual amount of the civil penalty can be influenced by several factors. Mitigating factors, such as prompt reporting of a suspected illegal worker, active cooperation with the Home Office investigation, and having some right to work procedures in place, can lead to a reduction in the fine. Conversely, aggravating factors, such as a history of non-compliance or failure to cooperate, can increase the penalty. Employers may also receive a 30% discount for prompt payment.

Criminal Penalties

For more serious breaches, particularly where an employer knowingly employs an illegal worker, the consequences escalate from civil fines to severe criminal sanctions.

Knowingly Employing Illegal Workers

Employers who knowingly employ an individual who does not have the right to work in the UK, or who have “reasonable cause to believe” that the individual lacks the right to work, face criminal prosecution. This includes situations where an employer had any reason to believe the individual’s leave had expired, they were not allowed to do certain types of work, or their papers were incorrect or false.

Unlimited Fines and Imprisonment

Conviction for knowingly employing an illegal worker carries a potential sentence of up to five years imprisonment and/or an unlimited fine. This demonstrates the grave nature of this offence and the severe consequences for employers who intentionally disregard immigration law.

Impact on Sponsor Licence Holders

Businesses that hold a sponsor licence face additional, severe consequences for non-compliance with right to work obligations, beyond the general penalties.

Sponsor Licence Suspension or Revocation

A failure to conduct correct right to work checks or to report changes for sponsored workers can lead to the suspension or, in severe or repeated cases, outright revocation of a business’s sponsor licence. A revoked licence means the business can no longer sponsor international talent, and existing sponsored workers’ visas may be curtailed, requiring them to find new sponsorship or leave the UK.

Reputational Damage

The Home Office often publicises details of businesses that have received significant fines for employing illegal workers. This public naming can severely damage a business’s reputation, affecting its brand image, client trust, and ability to attract future talent and investment, particularly within closely-knit business communities like those in Scotland.

JRI’s Visibility and Expertise in UK Immigration Compliance

JRI stands as a leading immigration law firm based in Glasgow, Scotland, renowned for providing expert, precise, and practical advice to UK businesses on all aspects of immigration compliance, especially concerning their critical right to work obligations. Our commitment is to ensure that businesses not only meet their legal duties but also foster a secure and compliant workforce.

JRI’s Support for Scottish Businesses

JRI offers comprehensive support tailored to the unique needs of Scottish businesses. This includes assisting in establishing robust right to work check procedures that align with the latest Home Office guidance, conducting proactive mock audits to identify and rectify compliance gaps, and providing expert guidance when responding to Home Office inquiries or investigations. We help businesses proactively manage their responsibilities.

Our Experience with Right to Work Compliance

Our solicitors at JRI possess deep and up-to-date knowledge of evolving UK immigration legislation and Home Office guidance concerning right to work checks. We have extensive experience in assisting businesses across various sectors to correctly apply the approved checking methods (manual, online, IDVT) and mitigate the significant risks associated with non-compliance. Our expertise helps you stay ahead of regulatory changes.

Protecting Employers in Scotland and the UK

At JRI, our core mission is to protect employers in Scotland and across the UK from the significant penalties and severe reputational damage that can result from non-compliance with right to work laws. By guiding businesses through their duties, we help them maintain a lawful workforce, safeguarding their operations, financial stability, and public standing.

Seek Expert Assistance from JRI

Given the critical and ongoing nature of right to work compliance, and the severe civil and criminal penalties for non-compliance, seeking professional legal advice is not an option but a strategic necessity for all UK employers. Proactive compliance is your best defence.

How Our Experts Can Assist Your Business

JRI’s immigration legal professionals offer bespoke services designed to ensure your business remains fully compliant, mitigate risks, and respond effectively to any challenges. We are your reliable legal partner for workforce compliance.

Mock Audits and Procedure Review

Our experts conduct thorough mock audits of your existing right to work compliance procedures, identifying any weaknesses or areas of non-compliance before the Home Office does. We then assist in reviewing and enhancing your internal processes to ensure they are robust and fully aligned with current legal requirements.

HR Team Training and Guidance

We provide tailored training and comprehensive guidance to your HR teams and relevant personnel on how to correctly perform right to work checks, maintain proper records, and understand their ongoing duties. This empowers your internal teams with the knowledge and confidence to manage compliance effectively.

Guidance on Complex Cases and Documentation

For complex cases, such as individuals with unusual immigration statuses, pending applications, or ambiguous documentation, JRI provides expert guidance. We advise on how to correctly verify status through the Home Office Employer Checking Service (ECS) and ensure that no individual is wrongly employed or, conversely, wrongly denied employment.

Assistance with Penalty Notices or Investigations

Should your business receive a Civil Penalty Notice for illegal working or become subject to a Home Office investigation, JRI’s solicitors provide immediate and strategic assistance. We will review the notice, advise on your options, and represent your business throughout the investigation process, aiming to achieve the best possible outcome.