This blog post is designed to empower you with a professional, clear understanding of your two main options for recourse: requesting an Administrative Review (AR) or initiating a new Certificate of Sponsorship (CoS) process.
What Happens When a Skilled Worker Visa is Refused?
A visa refusal is an official decision from the Home Office to deny an application. The refusal is communicated via a formal letter that outlines the reasons for the decision. This letter is a critical document, as it forms the basis of any future action you may take. A refusal can disrupt project timelines, delay the start date of a key employee, and create a significant sense of uncertainty for both the business and the prospective worker.
The Immediate Impact on Your Business
The costs of a visa refusal extend far beyond the lost application fees. There are tangible costs, such as the delay in a key hire joining the team, which can impact project completion and revenue. There are also intangible costs, including the administrative burden of repeating the application process, the demoralising effect on the team, and the potential for losing the prospective employee to a business in another country.
The Two Main Options for Employers
Upon receiving a refusal, a Scottish employer has two paths forward. The first is to challenge the Home Office’s decision through a process called an Administrative Review (AR). The second is to simply accept the refusal and begin a brand-new visa application process from the start, which requires issuing a new Certificate of Sponsorship (CoS).
Understanding Administrative Review (AR)
An Administrative Review is a formal, internal process by which the Home Office re-examines a visa refusal decision. It is not an appeal, and it is not a fresh application. Its sole purpose is to determine whether the original caseworker made an error in their decision based on the evidence that was submitted with the initial application.
What is an Administrative Review?
An AR is an internal paper review conducted by a different Home Office caseworker who was not involved in the original decision. This new caseworker reviews the application, the refusal decision, and the AR request to see if a casework error was made. The review is a procedural check, not a re-evaluation of the merits of the entire case.
The purpose and limited scope of an AR.
The purpose of an AR is to correct a mistake, not to allow an applicant to submit new evidence or fix a poorly prepared initial application. The review is limited to the information that was available to the original caseworker at the time of their decision. This makes it a specific and targeted form of recourse.
The Grounds for Requesting an AR
To be successful, an AR request must be based on a valid casework error as defined by the Immigration Rules. You cannot simply disagree with the decision; you must prove that the caseworker made a specific, identifiable mistake.
Identifying an error in the initial decision.
Examples of casework errors include miscalculating a salary or points total; failing to consider a piece of evidence that was included in the original application; or applying the wrong immigration rule or policy to the case. The refusal letter should be scrutinised carefully to identify any of these potential errors.
The Alternative: A New Certificate of Sponsorship (CoS)
The alternative to an AR is to accept the visa refusal and begin a new application. This requires the Scottish employer to issue a new Certificate of Sponsorship (CoS) and the prospective employee to submit a brand-new application, paying all the associated fees again.
The Steps to a New CoS Process
Starting a new CoS process means a complete restart. You would need to assign a new CoS, the employee would have to fill out a new application form, and all the supporting documents would need to be re-compiled and submitted.
The time, cost, and effort involved.
This route is significantly more time-consuming and expensive. You will have to pay the new visa application fee, the Immigration Health Surcharge, and potentially the CoS fee again. The processing time for a new application is usually several weeks or months, which means further delays for your business.
The Disadvantages of a New CoS
Choosing to start a new application may seem like a safe option, but it comes with several disadvantages. It is a long, costly, and resource-intensive process.
Risk of repeating the same mistake.
The biggest risk of a new CoS application is that if you do not correctly identify and address the reason for the first refusal, you may simply repeat the same mistake and face a second refusal. Without expert advice, it can be difficult to pinpoint the exact issue.
The Advantages of Choosing an Administrative Review
When the original refusal contains a clear casework error, an Administrative Review is often the superior choice for a Scottish business. It is a more strategic and efficient way to resolve the issue.
Speed and Efficiency
An AR can lead to a much quicker resolution. Because it is an internal review of an existing application, the Home Office typically aims to provide a decision more quickly than for a brand-new visa application. This means your employee could start sooner.
Cost-Effectiveness for Your Business
The fee for an Administrative Review is significantly lower than a full visa application. Moreover, if the AR is successful and the Home Office reverses its original decision, the AR fee is fully refunded. This makes it a highly cost-effective option for your business.
A More Direct Solution
An AR is a targeted solution. It forces the Home Office to directly address and correct a specific error in their original decision. This provides a clear, documented resolution that prevents the same mistake from being made again in the future.
Important Considerations and Risks
While an AR is often the best choice, it is not without its limitations and risks. It is crucial to understand these factors before deciding.
The Strict Time Limit for an AR
Time is of the essence. You have a short window to submit an AR request: 14 days from the date of the refusal notice for applications made within the UK and 28 days for applications made from outside the UK. Missing this deadline will prevent you from pursuing the AR route.
The AR is Not a New Appeal
It is vital to remember that an AR is not a chance to submit new evidence or build a new case. If the original application was weak or missing key documents, an AR is unlikely to succeed. In such cases, a new, prepared CoS application may be the only viable option.
When to Seek Professional Legal Advice
The decision of whether to pursue an AR or start a new CoS process is a strategic one with serious implications for your business. It is a decision that should not be made without consulting a professional.
Assessing Your Chances of Success
An experienced immigration solicitor can review the refusal letter and quickly determine if a clear casework error has been made. They can advise you on the merits of an AR and recommend the most strategic path forward, saving you from a costly and time-consuming mistake.
What a Solicitor Can Do for Your AR Request
A solicitor can be invaluable in this process. They will draft a compelling AR request that clearly and precisely highlights the caseworker’s error, ensuring the submission is made within the strict time limits and meets all procedural requirements. Their expertise dramatically increases your chances of a successful outcome.
How JRI Law Experts Can Assist You
At JRI, we specialise in providing expert business immigration advice to Scottish employers. We understand the pressures you face when a key hire visa application is refused. Our team provides swift, accurate, and cost-effective solutions. We will work with you to analyse the refusal, determine the best course of action, and execute a plan that gets your employee to work in Scotland as quickly as possible.
Expert Advice on Administrative Reviews
Our solicitors have extensive experience with Administrative Reviews. We can quickly review your refusal letter, identify any casework errors, and provide you with a frank assessment of your chances of success. Our knowledge of the Immigration Rules means we can build a compelling case for an AR that gets results.
Ensuring Your AR Request is Correctly Submitted
The procedural requirements for an AR are strict, and a minor error can lead to the request being rejected. We handle all the administrative details, from drafting the request to ensuring it is submitted within the 14-day or 28-day deadline, giving you the peace of mind that your case is in the best possible hands.
